Department of Surgery
Specialties
Patient Care
Education
Research
Faculty
Ways of Giving
Arizona Surgical Technology Education Center
calendar
Search
 
    © 2002 Arizona Board of Regents
    Last updated:
   Please send comments or questions to    webmaster@surgery.arizona.edu
 

UA medical students learn the importance of body language
by trying to get horses to complete simple tasks.

     The five denim-clad medical students were at a loss. All their scientific book learning couldn't help them now.
     They were looking at a nervous 1,000-pound horse that wouldn't do its part to complete a basic exercise. They ran at Mahto, flailed their arms and yelled, "Ha!" in an effort to move him into a corner of the sand-filled arena.
     Just when they thought they'd got him going in the right direction, he bolted the other way.
     Dr. Allan Hamilton, who on this windy Saturday afternoon had exchanged his white coat for boots, jeans and a cowboy hat looked on, a bemused smile twitching beneath his mustache. Gathering the students, he asked them what they thought was going wrong.
     "He's spooked," they responded.
     "Why is he spooked? Five jackasses running around with a lot of energy in their bodies!" he boomed good-naturedly to their laughter. "You guys are putting too much energy into your body language."
     Regrouping, the students approached the animal with less energy. Working together to form a human fence, they soon maneuvered the paint stallion into the corner.


  The exercise the University of Arizona College of Medicine students had just completed on a grassy ranch off Tanque Verde Road was part of an unusual class that uses horses to teach future doctors how to be better communicators.
     Called Medicine and Horsemanship, the class is the only one of its type in the United States.
 
     While no one is equating horses to humans, Hamilton said working with horses teaches patience, gentleness and nonverbal communication skills, all of which are essential to a good doctor-patient relationship.
     "This is a dramatic shortcut to some of those skills," said Hamilton, a neurosurgeon, UA professor and head of the department of surgery.
     "Horsemanship requires the exquisite understanding of nonverbal communication and the sensitivity to the import of body language" is the way Hamilton explained it in his written class description.
     "There is no endeavor that will more quickly and effectively teach you awareness of your own body language and energy level than learning the principles of round pen groundwork with horses."
     "Horses are so perceptive," said first-year medical student Wendi Kulin. "You can't make any false moves around a horse."
     Hamilton began offering the class three semesters ago, and word is quickly spreading.
     "We've had calls from all over the United States from medical students asking about it," Hamilton said.
     The noncredit class consists of eight sessions. After learning about horse safety, the students spend the next seven sessions engaged in horsemanship exercises. They learn to soothe, guide and teach tasks to the horses. They don't ride them. Most of the students have little or no experience with horses.

 

After the class, they discuss how the lesson applies to patient care scenarios.
     Hamilton said the exercise with Mahto demonstrated things about energy and teamwork that he could have talked himself "blue in the face" trying to teach as effectively.
     One of the key lessons, Hamilton explained in the discussion session afterward, was, "When you put too much energy into the system, the system gets out of control."

 
Imagine a team of doctors, nurses and technicians called together to care for a victim of a car accident or a shooting. The resident comes running into the trauma bay filled with a sense of urgency and out of breath.
     The message being given, Hamilton said, is, "Good God, this situation is out of control! Look what kind of condition he's in."
     "You want to bring the energy level down because bringing it down makes thing more efficient," he said.
     Slow you breathing. Lower your voice. And never run to a trauma, he advised the students.
     Hamilton, who is from New York City, began training horses a decade ago. He soon saw how what he was learning working with horses applied to his profession.
     Hamilton recognized his manner of striding up to a patient could be perceived as aggressive. He noticed that groups of doctors on rounds charged into a patient's room like invading soldiers. He saw that patients were sometimes treated like "a slab of meat," prodded and poked by a doctor with little warning.
     "If you did that with a horse, it would jump out the window," he said.
     A physical examine should be reassuring, he said. With appropriate use of touch, such as patting the patient on the shoulder or holding a patient's wrist to take a pulse even though machines check pulses now a doctor establishes a bond with the patient, Hamilton said.
     And that's not so different from the way a good horseman initiates contact with a horse by gentle stroking and petting, he said.
     "We spend so little time on teaching doctors to communicate effectively and develop bonds with their patients… .Yet, in no bond outside of marriage is the sincerity and integrity of communication so important," Hamilton said.
     Kulin and other students said the class has been an invaluable experience.
     "Dr. Hamilton's idea is that learning how to be non-threatening and give off a really positive and approachable attitude is a really good thing to have when you are dealing with patients normally," Kulin said.
     "We have such little time with patients today that you don't want to blow it by seeming arrogant when you come in the room."
     "If you're more conscious of how you act, it will come across to the patient," said second-year student Mohammad Vaziri. "It's not only our job to treat the patient but to make the experience as least traumatic as possible."
 
More information on the Horsemanship Elective
Information about Alan Hamilton, MD
AHSC Logl Department of Surgery